Czech and Slovak air reforms: a chance for alignment

Slovakia’s purchase of the F-16V, expiration of the Czech Gripen lease - opportunity to align the Czech and Slovak...

Czech and Slovak air reforms: a chance for alignment
Jetfighters (Zdroj: Pixabay/Malachi Witt)
Písmo: A- | A+
Diskusia  (0)

S radosťou predstavujeme nášho nového spolupracovníka:
Frederick Hardman Lea.
Fred študuje svoju ďalšiu školu - krízový a bezpečnostný manažment na Justice Institute of British Columbia. Jeho dlhodobou vášňou sú, okrem iného, technológie, trendy v oblasti obrany a bezpečnosti.
Jeho analytické práce nám prinášajú potrebný kontext a nadhľad pri posudzovaní situácie a diania a to nielen v strednej Európe.
Fred píše zatiaľ v angličtine (sľúbil, že sa naučí po slovensky:). Niektoré jeho práce budeme uverejňovať na stránkach ICE. Dnes publikujeme jeho pohľad na proces obstarania (a príležitostí na spoluprácu) finančne najnáročnejšieho segmentu ozbrojených síl - nadzvukového letectva - v Čechách a na Slovensku.

Fred, welcome and good luck!

Slovakia’s purchase of the F-16V and the coming expiration of the Czech Gripen lease present anopportunity to align the Czech and Slovak air forces around a common combat jet platform, the F16.

Aligning air forces would improve interoperability and coordination; it could also lead to programs that would reduce costs for both air forces (especially in training). This would increase the effectiveness of the “Joint Sky” agreement through which each state has agreed to protect the other’s airspace. For years the Slovak government appeared on the verge of adopting the Gripen, aligning themselves with regional partners, namely Czechia and Hungary. However, in 2018 Slovakia agreed to purchase the F-16 from the US company Lockheed Martin. Now, if Czechia and Slovakia aim to align their air forces, Czechia will have to also acquire the F-16.

Skryť Vypnúť reklamu
Článok pokračuje pod video reklamou

Currently, the Czechs lease twelve (plus two training models) 4th generation Gripen jets from the Swedish air force. These are capable multi-role aircraft developed by Saab. Given the experience, infrastructure, and logistics developed from operating the Gripen, it may be difficult to persuade the Czechs of the benefits of operating the F-16, which is really no better in capability than the Gripen.

There are at least four options available to the Czechs to replace their Gripen lease:

1) Simply stay with the Gripen in an updated, leased, or purchased form;

2) Purchase Lockheed Martin’s F-16 4th generation mutli-role platform;

Skryť Vypnúť reklamu

3) Purchase a European platform like the French Rafael or the multinational Eurofighter (a group project from the UK, Germany, and Italy). Both are 4th generation multi role platforms;

4) Purchase Lockheed Martin’s 5th generation multi-role platform, the F-35.

The benefits of option 1 are, as previously stated, that the Czechs can build upon their existing experience and infrastructure to operate the Gripen. Option 2 would see the Czechs step in line with regional partners, including Slovakia, Poland, Bulgaria, and Romania who have or are in the process of acquiring F-16s, which creates an opportunity for partnerships across the region. Option 3 would see the Czechs operate a European platform, that would provide options for cooperation with regional and powerful NATO allies like France (if the Rafael is chosen), or Germany, Italy, Austria, and the UK (if the Eurofighter Typhoon is chosen).  However, the cost of operating these platforms twice exceeds the cost of operating the F-16 and is four times the cost of the Gripen (approximately $17,000 per hour for the Eurofighter and Rafael, versus $7,000 for the F-16 and $4,700 for the Gripen), making them too expensive for central European air forces.

Skryť Vypnúť reklamu

Option 4 is the most alluring from a purely technical perspective. If Czechia operated the F35, it would become the second state in Central Europe (after Poland) to do so. The advanced stealth and maneuverability features of the F-35 would give the Czechs one of the more regionally powerful air forces. With the F35 becoming an unofficial NATO standard the fourth option would also give Czechia the ability to operate with strategic partners (such as the USA, UK, Italy, Poland, Denmark, and others) and make it easier to base allied air assets locally if necessary. However, its operating costs are even higher than the European options, at approximately $33,000 per hour. Such cost is hard, if not impossible, for the Czech Air Force to justify. Even the jobs brought in by admittance to the Joint Strike Fighter program (as each program partner is entitled to some parts production) would not be enough to justify this operating cost.

Skryť Vypnúť reklamu

The best options are therefore for the Czech Air Force to operate either the Gripen or F-16. These remain viable combat platforms with the benefits of being reliable and having low operating costs. The Gripen’s manufacturer (Saab) is very flexible in making deals, allowing for leasing and domestic production in some deals (such as in Brazil). Lockheed Martin, the manufacturer of the F-16, too makes increasingly better deals. In addition, like the F-35, the F-16 is an unofficial NATO standard but without the cost or inevitable troubleshooting that come from operating the F-35 at this time.

If the F-16 and the Gripen are the only realistic options to replace the Czech Gripen lease, shouldn’t the Czechs opt for the F-16 on the basis that it can be aligned with its key regional partners? The operating costs can be brought down to Gripen levels through cooperation as the fuel consumption and parts usage can be offset by reduced training costs, better deals for spare parts, and an increase in combat effectiveness. While the operating costs may remain higher than the Gripen, selection of a new combat jet must not simply be a matter of cost, but the result of a cost-benefit analysis that recognizes the value of the regional alignment of air forces.

Inštitút pre strednú Európu

Inštitút pre strednú Európu

Bloger 
  • Počet článkov:  2
  •  | 
  • Páči sa:  3x

Bringing Europe together - “Veríme, že je čas prebudiť potenciál, ktorý v sebe stredná Európa má a premeniť ho na produktívne úsilie o spoločné dobro obyvateľov zo všetkých kútov Európy.” Svet, Európa i Slovensko dnes stoja na prahu vážnych zmien, ktoré ovplyvnia životy nás všetkých. Klimatická zmena, vyčerpanosť ekonomického modelu, meniace sa siločiary v globálnom geopolitickom prostredí, spolu s novými bezpečnostnými hrozbami posúvajú vnímanie bezpečnosti a prosperity do novej dimenzie. Vyžadujú novú úroveň pripravenosti a formovanie postojov nielen od našich vlád, ale celého verejného i súkromného sektora. Prichádza obdobie, v ktorom uspejú tí, ktorí nástrahy novej doby dokážu premeniť na príležitosti. V ICE sme presvedčení, že ak chce Slovensko v tomto príbehu stáť na strane úspešných, musí byť pripravené nielen na úrovni národných politík, ale koordinovať tieto politiky aj na regionálnej úrovni a aktívne prispievať k ich formovaniu na úrovni Európskej Únie. https://icesk.eu Zoznam autorových rubrík:  NezaradenéSúkromné

Prémioví blogeri

Lucia Šicková

Lucia Šicková

3 články
Karolína Farská

Karolína Farská

4 články
Juraj Hipš

Juraj Hipš

12 článkov
Adam Valček

Adam Valček

6 článkov
Milota Sidorová

Milota Sidorová

2 články
Skryť Zatvoriť reklamu